The highest court in Massachusetts recently ruled in Daikin Applied Americas Inc. v. Russo that employers seeking a preliminary injunction to stop former employees from misappropriating the employer’s confidential information and/or trade secrets must independently show that the employer will suffer “irreparable harm” (i.e., harm that cannot be compensated with money damages) without the injunction in order for the court to grant such relief.
Significantly, the Daikin court held that establishing a likelihood of success on the merits of the underlying claims (in this case, trade secrets claims) does not create a presumption of irreparable harm sufficient to enter a preliminary injunction.
The Dispute
The Daikin case involved a commercial HVAC company (Daikin), who alleged that two of its former employees took its confidential information and used the stolen information to solicit Daikin’s customers for a competing business. Daikin filed suit and sought a preliminary injunction against the employees that would bar them from soliciting Daikin’s customers for one year.
Why Daikin’s Preliminary Injunction Request Failed
Like many states, Massachusetts requires a party to show the following to receive a preliminary injunction:
- it is likely to succeed on the merits of its claims;
- it will suffer irreparable harm in the absence of the requested injunction; and
- the risk of irreparable harm to the requesting party outweighs the harm to the non-requesting party.
Daikin argued that it could show a likelihood of success on the merits of its underlying trade secret claims and therefore it was entitled to a “presumption” that it would suffer irreparable harm without the requested injunctive relief.
The judge disagreed, finding that there is no such presumption and that the party requesting the injunction must establish “specific proof” of irreparable harm. And, because Daikin failed to present any evidence that it would suffer irreparable harm without the injunction, and was able only able to point to harm that could be remedied by payment of money damages, the judge upheld the lower court’s denial of Daikin’s injunction request.