The DOJ’s Civil Rights Division and EEOC recently settled with Cloudera Inc. and Maplebear Inc., which does business as Instacart. The government alleged that both companies discriminated against U.S. workers during Permanent Labor Certification (PERM) recruitment in favor of workers on temporary employment visas.
Cloudera
Under a joint settlement with DOJ and the Department of Labor (DOL), Cloudera will be barred from PERM for two years. It will also fund a $1.4 million back-pay pool, pay $600,000 in civil penalties and accept monitoring.
Instacart
On October 20, 2026, DOJ and the EEOC announced a $5 million settlement with Instacart. The government alleged that Instacart required U.S. applicants to mail in their applications rather than apply online. Instacart will pay $4 million into a fund for applicants, including people who were discouraged from applying, and $1 million in civil penalties.
These cases apply existing rules under the Immigration and Nationality Act, Title VII and PERM regulations. Notably, now the DOJ, DOL and the EEOC are enforcing them together.
Employers using PERM should make sure to use the same application channels, burdens and review standards for every applicant. They should also be able to show that their recruitment and hiring processes are non-discriminatory based on all protected classes, including national origin.